Tuesday 3 November 2026International EditionRSSMembers
The financial daily of the startup economy
Markets

Oil's biggest fall since July lifts cyclicals but leaves growth investors waiting

Crude lost more than 7% on Monday as Washington and Tehran signalled room for talks. Bonds rallied and consumer stocks jumped, yet the S&P 500 and the Nasdaq closed lower as technology sold off.

· · 5 min read
Macro photograph for: Oil's biggest fall since July lifts cyclicals but leaves growth investors waiting
Illustration: Invest Times

Oil had its worst session in more than three months on Monday, November 2. West Texas Intermediate fell 7.4% to settle at $96.46 a barrel, its biggest daily loss since July 27, and Brent dropped 7.6% to $104.77, as both Washington and Tehran signalled that a negotiated end to the eight-month conflict in the Middle East was still on the table. The move erased a large part of the war premium that had pushed crude up by more than 10% in October.

The reaction across asset classes was telling. Treasury yields fell, the Dow Jones Industrial Average rose 0.41% to 51,983.98 and consumer, financial and industrial shares rallied. Yet the S&P 500 lost 0.51% to 7,541.40, while the Nasdaq Composite fell 1.07%. Cheaper energy helped the parts of the market that burn fuel and depend on household spending. It did not help the parts that depend on investors' appetite for long-duration growth, and that distinction matters for anyone valuing private technology companies.

What moved the price

The trigger was a cluster of conciliatory statements over the weekend and on Monday. President Donald Trump said Iran wants to make a deal. Secretary of State Marco Rubio said the president had not made a decision on new strikes and would prefer to resolve the conflict diplomatically. In Tehran, President Masoud Pezeshkian said the government would try to settle the dispute through dialogue, with authority for talks granted by Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei, and Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi said an agreement was possible if Washington showed goodwill.

According to Oilprice.com, Araghchi also said negotiators in Qatar were working on a proposal that could reopen the Strait of Hormuz in as little as two days if the United States met several conditions, including an end to the naval blockade of Iranian ports and the lifting of oil sanctions. He added that Iran is not holding direct talks with the United States.

None of this amounts to a settlement, and the counter-signals were loud. Khamenei called on Saturday for the armed forces to answer threats with an immediate and unrestricted response. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu urged a resumption of strikes after Tuesday's midterm elections. A projectile was reported to have hit a vessel in the Strait of Hormuz on Sunday. Ryan McKay of TD Securities told CNBC that much of October's gain had been risk premium, but that he did not expect diplomatic headlines alone to remove it while tanker attacks continue.

Goldman Sachs, cited by Oilprice.com, estimates the geopolitical premium at about $27 a barrel and has raised its December Brent forecast to $105 from $90. Monday's settlement sits almost exactly on that number. The market has not priced peace. It has priced a lower probability of escalation.

A rotation, not a rally

Beneath the headline indices, Monday was a broad day for most stocks. CappNotes' closing data show consumer discretionary up 2.41%, financials up 1.86% and materials up 1.76%, with eight of the eleven S&P 500 sectors higher. The equal-weighted S&P 500 ETF rose 0.76%, beating the market-capitalisation index by more than a point, and mid caps and small caps in the S&P indices each gained close to 0.8%. Advancing issues outnumbered decliners by more than two to one.

The losers were concentrated. Energy fell 3.96% and technology 2.95%. Among Dow members, Sherwin-Williams gained about 6% and Home Depot about 3.6%, while Microsoft, Apple and Nvidia all closed lower. Grocers rallied on lower fuel costs. Company news added to the pressure on technology, with Oracle and Marvell both falling sharply on financing and deal announcements, but the sector weakness was wider than any single name.

The same pattern appeared in Asia on Tuesday morning. Seoul Economic Daily reported that South Korean refiner S-Oil fell 11.46% in early trade, with SK Innovation and GS also lower, as Monday's crude settlement fed through to local markets.

What it does to rates

The most direct channel from oil to startup valuations runs through bonds. With lower crude easing inflation concerns, the 10-year Treasury yield fell 3.5 basis points to 4.893% and the 30-year by 4.1 basis points to 5.268%, according to CappNotes. The 2-year yield was little changed at 4.581%.

That shape is important. A rally confined to longer maturities says investors marked down the inflation risk embedded in long bonds, but did not change their view of the next moves by the Federal Reserve. CME FedWatch still showed a 72% probability of a December rate increase. The economic data published the same day gave the central bank little reason to relax: the ISM manufacturing index for October came in at 55.5, above the 54.5 consensus, with its prices component at 75.2, while construction spending fell 1.9% in September against expectations of a small gain.

In other words, Monday shaved some of the inflation premium off long-term rates without touching the policy path. For companies whose value lies mostly in cash flows a decade away, a lower long yield is welcome. A Fed that may still tighten is not.

Why growth did not benefit

There are 3 reasons technology lagged on a day when the discount rate fell. The first is positioning. Investors have spent several weeks questioning the returns on AI infrastructure spending, and the Nasdaq and the S&P 500 both ended October with losses. A day of relief elsewhere gave holders an opportunity to trim crowded positions rather than add to them.

The second is that the beneficiaries of cheaper oil are obvious and immediate: airlines, retailers, homebuilders, chemicals and grocers see costs fall within weeks. The benefit to a growth company comes indirectly, through rates and through the risk appetite of institutional buyers, and that channel is slower and less certain.

The third is volatility. The VIX rose 8.91% to 21.15, back above 20, even as most stocks rose. Gold gained 1.49%. Investors were hedging against the possibility that the diplomatic signals fail, as they have before. CNBC noted that previous rumours of a settlement have been followed by renewed fighting and new price spikes.

Our view

Monday was a useful reminder that the energy shock, not technology earnings, sets the tone for the cost of capital this autumn. A durable fall in crude would pull long yields lower and give late-stage companies and their investors a better backdrop for funding rounds and listings. A single day of hopeful statements does not.

For founders, the practical point is that the rotation favoured businesses with visible, near-term cash flows that benefit from lower input costs. Investors are rewarding tangible relief, not distant optionality. Growth valuations will only gain if lower oil persists long enough to change the Federal Reserve's December calculation, and the market still puts a hike as the more likely outcome.

What to watch: whether talks mediated by Qatar produce anything concrete on the Strait of Hormuz, how markets digest the midterm results given repeated warnings that escalation could follow the vote, and whether the 10-year yield can hold below 4.9%. Until then, energy headlines will keep doing the work that rate cuts are not.

Sources

Filed under Markets. Written by Invest Times Editorial under our editorial standards. Commentary and analysis for information only, not investment advice.

More in Markets

All Markets analysis